Firstly, I will admit that I'm posting this on devart rather than my LJ because I have alot of overseas cosplayers watching me and this seems like the kind of issue that alot of you might have interest in. If you're Danish, even more awesome, we're giving a panel tomorrow at 11am so you can ask questions....which imho is absolutely ridiculous, this NEVER happens in Asian countries, so I'm Asian at heart...sue me...
I was very kindly invited to judge the Denmark WCS round @ J-pop con by the organizers who I met at this year's WCS, and it was a really big honour for me because I've only judged a couple of small competitions and karaokes before this. My fellow judges were bell and iris, the 2 german reps for WCS 2009 and Nadia, a highly respected italian cosplayer who's also been a past WCS contestant. Personally I felt this was a good move on the organizers part because firstly, we don't know any of the contestants which reduces bias and at the same time the judges have had first-hand experience at WCS (most of us the recent one) I confess I've never judged anything of this scale before but I've been cosplaying for well on 7 years now, and I've attended cons in 7 countries and done WCS, so I think that at least gives my opinion some backing.
There was apparently some "scandal" though that might be exaggerated because I have yet to see for myself the extent of this dissent over the judges choice for the Danish WCS representatives for 2010. (I'd like to add it happened approx 4-5 hours after the results were announced and the unhappy parties complained to the organizers which led me to think firstly...wow...lag....secondly, why on earth are you guys making it difficult for the organizers, shouldn't the blame go to the judges if you're not happy about the decision?) And although I can understand why our choice may have seemed unorthodox, I did mention why we chose who we did before we annouced the results, which I will elaborate further on in awhile. I have also led to understand that part of the anger was due to
1. what was seen as the organizers and judges to coercing a team who originally was not running for WCS into taking part
2. for the "three degree interrogation" that the 2 teams that we were highly undecided upon were subjected to (4 judges, it was split 2/2)
An overview of the situation. No point not mentioning names since you guys will obviously google and I'm pretty sure you'll find out who I'm talking about 1 min within reading this post, and I reckon our names (judges) must be all over 4-chan by now
The 2 groups that the judges were pretty much undecided about were mononoke and halloween kingdom hearts. When I say we were undecided what I mean was, 2 judges rooting very very strongly for 1 team and the other supporting the other team all the way. My personal choice was Halloween kindgom hearts.
Mononoke was what I would call a technically good choice for WCS. They had excellent workmanship, beautiful costumes and they had a couple of props which were nice, although there was some technicality issues about it which I will not go into. However, their skit was nothing stunning, it was good considering the nature of the series, basically a scenario of the medicine man exorcising a demon and I felt it did indeed capture the essence of the show, but they lacked what I call the X-factor.
Now you may not think much of the X-factor, but I would like to point out that Japan won this year's WCS competition, and in all honesty, they did not have the best costumes, nor the best skit, but I felt they had something that was lacking in many other teams. There was a quality about their performance that cannot be explained in anything other than an urge to sit up and really pay attention to what they were doing.
J-pop con gave me beautiful costumes and some really awesome(amusing) skits, but I can safely say, the only team that made me sit up in my seat and pay attention (both figuratively and literally) was the Halloween Kingdom Hearts team. They did not have the most elaborate costume, in fact I didn't even notice them until bell pointed them out to me during pre-judging, and even then I didn't really take note. Even when they came on stage they didn't feel very professional or particularly amazing, but when they started their performance, I was......for lack of a better word, enthralled. The gist of their skit was Halloween Sora meeting a "dead ballerina" version of Halloween Kairi and then a creepy very visually powerful dance followed. In itself it was nothing particularly spectaular, but many many elements came together to make in superb, like the lighting, the chemistry between the cosplayers...dude, just youtube it. My instant reaction after it ended was to check my judging sheet to see if this team was doing WCS and I cannot describe my disappointment that they apparently were not. Apparently I was so intensly captivated by them that I didn't realize that the cheering for them was really loud, which many people pointed out to be later.
What followed after was that I actually said this to one of the organizers, that I was very disappointed that the KH team wasn't competing because I would have loved to sent them to WCS and as we were about to adjourn to discuss the results, I was suddenly told that the KH team suddenly wanted to run for WCS. And this is where the chaos begins.
It wasn't that the KH didn't want to do WCS (who doesn't) it was because they thought that Halloween Kairi, being an original design would not be allowed to compete. I would like to point out that nothing in the WCS rules specifically applies to this and that there have been WCS finalists who have done costumes that technically don't exist, as in they are original or partially original designs, such as USA 2009 and the Japanese Code Geass team from 1-2 years back. When we told them that they could possibly be considered as we thought original costumes of an existing character, especially since we could identify her as kairi, were fine, it seemed to me that they actually wanted to try out for the running.
If there was any coercing going on, I can say it only happened, when I sent the organizers out with a direct command, go and confirm for me if they want to take part. I told them to tell the KH team that we really loved their performance and we thought they had potential and that we had to know NOW if they wanted to be considered because results were due in an hour. I would like to make it clear that the team had every intention to take part but did not due to rule-issues which they qualified for in the end.
However, despite this, I still felt a little uncertain, because I personally felt that the KH team did not seem particularly confident nor prepared to do WCS, and the more I thought about it, the more I felt that I really wanted to speak to them myself to determine if they were suitable to represent Denmark in a world convention. Upon my insistance, it was decided that we should speak to both teams, so I will take responsibility for the occurance of this "third degree interrogation" but as it was, I felt this was the best way for me make a final decision, because someone had to break the tie. That being said, even if I had chosen mononoke in the end, I don't think I would have been able to live with myself after that, knowing I had not chosen the team that I supported with all my heart.
The questions we asked were pretty similar for both teams. To the mononoke it was, why should we choose you, what do you have to offer, what would you do in Japan if you won, would you try again if you didn't, why you cosplay and the like. It was not just the answers I based my decision upon, it was how they replied, their body language, everything, actually in retrospect, yeah that's kinda like third-degree interrogation isn't it? Though I don't see why people should complain, don't you Danish want the best that your country can offer for WCS? cause I know I want the best singapore can give to go to nagoya next year.
To the KH team...I confess, I was horrible, I was downright mean, but it was because I loved this team so much that I wanted to be 100% sure that they wanted it, and that they could handle it, I didn't want their WCS experience to be ruined by because I was a bad judge and sent a team that wasn't prepared despite the fact they had so much potential. We asked why they didn't run straight for WCS, reason above stated, the usual, what they wanted to do if they got there, would they try again, why they cosplay and I straight out asked them, were they prepared. I was so straighforward on that and I came down so harsh on them I made one of them cry. As bad as I feel about it, talking to the two teams really cemented it for me that KH was the one I wanted to send to WCS. Their replies I will not speak of here because some of the things we asked I feel are personal (especially in the asian context, but suffice to say they reflected the type of cosplayers these 2 teams were)
To my surprise, one of the judges who was very strongly supportive of the mononoke team, but who at the same time also did like the KH team changed her mind after we talked to them. Simply put, though it might seem a little misleading. World Cosplay Summit for us has evolved to something more than just going to Japan with your best costumes and your best skits and showing the world what you can do, because in all honesty, whatever you can do, another country can do just as well if not better. Japan won because they had the X-factor, and KH won mononoke for the exact same reason. We were invited to choose a team that would best represent Denmark in a world summit that would involve the coming together of a group of people who share a similar passion (for me that passion shone through in the KH team's performance). We awarded mononoke with best group and best craftsmanship, something that I have been told has never happened before, because we felt that they deserved it. But it was the KH team that really made us feel like Denmark had a chance of winning WCS and for me that is the job of a judge, to pick out the best.
This will probably come across as very arrogant and in singaporean terms, bhb, but there was a reason why I was asked to be a judge. I have been to WCS, I have seen what is like, I have a grasp of what by WCS standards is good and what is not (no matter how strange those standards might be) and I do believe I know better than a person who thinks that cosplay is all about elaborate costumes and a good skit, because it is not. It is a hobby and what makes it such is because you do it purely based on passion, for the love, for the joy and the fun that it gives you. Jill and I did not win WCS, we were not the team with the best costumes, we were not the team with the best skit, but I can say that I do believe we did Singapore proud. I believe the best team that can possibly represent a country is one that does not go with their first and foremost thought as winning (though that is definately important) but to have fun, to learn, to make friends, and to do the best they possibly can, because passion is not the same as professionlism, because it is truly something that shows when cosplay is brought to the stage. And for me, it shone brillinatly in the KH team.